Process for dealing with research misconduct

Creative Science addresses allegations of research and publication misconduct through a fair, confidential, and evidence-based process, consistent with COPE guidance. All concerns are assessed according to their nature, seriousness, and potential impact on the integrity of the scholarly record.

Reporting Suspected Misconduct

Concerns may be reported by authors, reviewers, readers, editors, institutions, or other parties to the editorial office at csj@snru.ac.th.

Reports should identify the manuscript or published article, describe the suspected misconduct, and include supporting evidence where available. The journal will handle reports confidentially as far as reasonably possible. There is no time limit on raising concerns about a published article.

Preliminary Assessment

The Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor will conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the allegation warrants further investigation.

The assessment may include:

  1. Reviewing the information and evidence provided.
  2. Examining the manuscript, published article, or editorial records.
  3. Assessing the seriousness and potential impact of the concern.
  4. Identifying any conflicts of interest among those involved in the assessment.
  5. Determining whether additional information or expert advice is needed.

An allegation alone does not establish misconduct.

Investigation and Author Response

When further investigation is necessary, the journal may:

  1. Contact the corresponding author and, where appropriate, other co-authors for clarification.
  2. Request original data, research records, ethics approvals, permissions, or other relevant documents.
  3. Consult independent experts or editorial board members.
  4. Examine similarity reports, figures, data, manuscript histories, or peer-review records.
  5. Refer matters requiring formal investigation to the authors' institutions or other appropriate bodies.

Authors will normally be given a reasonable opportunity to respond before a final editorial decision is made.

The journal will distinguish between honest errors and conduct that raises serious concerns about research integrity.

Editorial Decisions Before Publication

For manuscripts under review, the journal may:

  • Request clarification or additional evidence.
  • Require corrections or revisions.
  • Suspend consideration while serious concerns are examined.
  • Reject the manuscript when ethical or scientific concerns remain unresolved.
  • Refer the matter to the relevant institution when appropriate.

Decisions will be based on the available evidence and the seriousness of the concern.

Editorial Actions After Publication

When concerns arise after publication, the journal may take one or more of the following actions:

Correction: To address errors that do not undermine the reliability of the article's principal findings.

Expression of Concern: To alert readers to serious unresolved concerns about an article.

Retraction: To correct the scholarly record when the findings are unreliable or serious ethical or publication-integrity problems are established.

The journal may also notify relevant institutions, indexing services, or other appropriate parties when necessary.

Published notices will clearly identify the affected article and be linked to the original publication and its DOI, where applicable.

Confidentiality and Fairness

The journal will protect confidential information and avoid premature conclusions.

Editors with relevant conflicts of interest must not direct an investigation or determine its outcome.

All parties will be treated fairly, and editorial actions will be proportionate to the available evidence.

Post-Publication Discussion

Readers may submit substantive comments, corrections, or critiques concerning published articles to csj@snru.ac.th. The editorial office will assess such correspondence and, where warranted, invite a response from the authors and publish the exchange or issue an appropriate editorial notice.

Appeals and Complaints

Authors may appeal an editorial decision, and any party may submit a complaint about the journal’s processes or editorial staff, by writing to csj@snru.ac.th. Appeals should identify the decision being challenged, explain the grounds for reconsideration, and provide supporting evidence.

The journal aims to acknowledge appeals and complaints within 10 working days and to communicate an outcome within 60 days. Where practicable, an appeal will be reviewed by an editor or editorial representative who was not directly responsible for the original decision. An appeal does not guarantee that the original decision will be changed; the decision of the Editor-in-Chief is final.

Cooperation with Institutions

The journal may cooperate with universities, research institutions, funding agencies, or other authorized bodies when formal investigation is required.

Institutions are generally responsible for investigating allegations concerning the conduct of their researchers.

Creative Science retains responsibility for editorial decisions and any necessary corrections to its published record.