Publication ethics and publication malpractice statement
Creative Science is committed to publishing original, reliable, and ethically conducted research. The journal does not tolerate practices that compromise the integrity of scholarly work or the publication process.
Plagiarism and Originality
Submitted manuscripts must be original and must properly acknowledge the work of others. Plagiarism, including the unattributed use of another person’s text, ideas, data, figures, or other intellectual contributions, is prohibited.
All submissions are screened using Turnitin similarity-detection software. Submissions with an overall similarity index exceeding 25% are referred for editorial assessment. Similarity reports are evaluated by editors in context; a similarity percentage alone does not establish plagiarism, and neither does a percentage below the threshold exclude it.
Duplicate and Redundant Publication
Manuscripts must not be submitted to more than one journal simultaneously.
Authors must disclose any closely related publications, manuscripts under consideration, or prior dissemination that may overlap with the submitted work.
Duplicate or redundant publication without appropriate disclosure and justification is unacceptable.
Data Fabrication, Falsification, and Image Manipulation
Authors must report research data, methods, analyses, and findings accurately.
The fabrication or falsification of data, results, observations, or research procedures is prohibited.
Images and figures must not be manipulated in ways that misrepresent the original findings. Any adjustments must preserve the scientific meaning of the data and be disclosed when necessary.
Authorship and Contributorship
Authorship must reflect genuine scholarly contributions and accountability. Creative Science applies the authorship criteria of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Each author should have:
- made a substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data;
- drafted the work or revised it critically for important intellectual content;
- approved the final version to be published; and
- agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
Contributors who do not meet all four criteria should be recognized in the Acknowledgements rather than listed as authors. All authors must additionally provide a CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) statement describing their individual contributions.
Gift authorship, honorary authorship, ghost authorship, and the deliberate exclusion of qualifying contributors are unacceptable. Any change to authorship after submission must be justified and supported by the written agreement of all affected authors.
Conflicts of Interest
Authors, editors, and reviewers must disclose financial, professional, personal, or institutional relationships that could influence their work or judgment.
The journal will assess disclosed conflicts and take appropriate measures to protect the independence of the editorial and peer-review process.
Citation Integrity
References must be accurate, relevant, and appropriately attributed.
Citation manipulation, including coercive citation practices and unnecessary references intended to increase citation counts, is prohibited.
Peer-Review Integrity
Creative Science applies a double-blind peer-review process involving at least three qualified reviewers.
The journal prohibits fraudulent reviewer identities, fabricated reviews, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and attempts to manipulate editorial decisions.
Editors and reviewers must maintain the confidentiality and independence of peer review.
Research Ethics and Informed Consent
Research involving human participants or animals must comply with the journal's ethical requirements.
Authors must obtain the necessary ethics approvals, permissions, and informed consent when applicable and provide appropriate statements in their manuscripts.
Copyright and Intellectual Property
Authors must respect copyright and intellectual property rights.
Permission must be obtained for the reproduction of copyrighted materials when required.
All submissions must comply with the journal's published copyright and licensing policies.
Research Data, Transparency, and Data Availability
Authors should describe their methods and findings sufficiently to allow scholarly evaluation.
All articles must include a Data Availability Statement indicating where the data supporting the reported findings can be found, and under what conditions they may be accessed. Acceptable forms include:
- Data deposited in a public repository, with the repository name and accession number or DOI.
- Data included within the article or its supplementary materials.
- Data available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
- Data subject to restriction, with the reason stated (for example, privacy, confidentiality, or legal or ethical constraints).
The journal may request underlying data or supporting documentation when concerns arise. Any such request will take account of privacy, confidentiality, legal restrictions, and research ethics.
Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence
AI-assisted tools must be used responsibly and transparently.
Authors must verify AI-assisted content and disclose material AI use in accordance with the journal's AI policy.
AI must not be used to fabricate data, generate false references, manipulate scientific evidence, or conceal plagiarism.
Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
The journal will take appropriate action when significant errors or ethical concerns are identified after publication.
Correction: Issued when an error requires amendment but does not invalidate the article's principal findings.
Expression of Concern: Issued when serious concerns remain unresolved and readers should be informed.
Retraction: Issued when the findings are unreliable or serious ethical or publication-integrity problems justify removing the article's standing as reliable scholarly evidence.
Retractions are intended to correct the scholarly record rather than punish authors.
Notices will identify the affected article, explain the reason for the action, and remain linked to the original publication and its DOI, where applicable.
The original article will ordinarily remain accessible with a clear indication of its publication status, unless legal, privacy, or safety considerations require otherwise.