Ethics Role

Creative Science adheres to the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and follows COPE guidance and flowcharts when handling ethical concerns. The journal follows established principles of publication ethics to ensure fairness, transparency, and integrity throughout the editorial and peer-review process. The responsibilities of the publisher, editors, reviewers, and authors are outlined below.

Contact for ethical concerns, complaints, and appeals: csj@snru.ac.th

Duties of Editors

Editors are responsible for the quality, integrity, and fairness of the journal's editorial process.

Editors shall:

  1. Evaluate manuscripts based on originality, scientific merit, methodological soundness, clarity, and relevance to the journal's scope.
  2. Ensure that manuscripts undergo double-blind peer review by at least three qualified reviewers.
  3. Select reviewers with appropriate expertise and avoid assignments involving conflicts of interest.
  4. Make editorial decisions independently and without discrimination or undue influence.
  5. Ensure that all listed authors meet the journal’s authorship criteria, have approved the manuscript, and accept responsibility for their work.
  6. Identify and manage potential conflicts of interest in the editorial process.
  7. Address suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, authorship disputes, and other ethical concerns.
  8. Give authors a reasonable opportunity to respond to substantive allegations before reaching a decision.
  9. Take appropriate action when significant errors or ethical concerns are identified in published articles.
  10. Ensure that AI-assisted tools do not replace human editorial judgment or compromise manuscript confidentiality.

Duties of Authors

Authors are responsible for the originality, accuracy, and integrity of their submitted work.

Authors shall:

  1. Submit original work that has not been published previously or submitted simultaneously to another journal.
  2. Present research methods, data, results, and conclusions accurately and honestly.
  3. Avoid plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, misleading image manipulation, and inappropriate duplication of published material.
  4. Cite relevant sources accurately and acknowledge the contributions of others.
  5. Ensure that all listed authors have made appropriate contributions, approved the manuscript, and accepted responsibility for their work.
  6. Disclose funding sources and any actual or potential conflicts of interest.
  7. Obtain the necessary ethics approvals, permissions, and informed consent when applicable.
  8. Protect participants' privacy and the confidentiality of sensitive research information.
  9. Provide supporting data or documentation when reasonably requested, subject to legal and ethical restrictions.
  10. Promptly notify the editor of significant errors discovered during review or after publication.
  11. Disclose the use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools in accordance with the journal's AI policy.
  12. Verify all AI-assisted content and accept full responsibility for the submitted manuscript.

Duties of Reviewers

Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, and confidential assessments of submitted manuscripts.

Reviewers shall:

  1. Evaluate manuscripts fairly and provide clear, evidence-based comments.
  2. Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe or promptly notify the editor of any delay.
  3. Decline review invitations when they lack relevant expertise or have a conflict of interest.
  4. Treat manuscripts and all related materials as confidential.
  5. Not use unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal or professional advantage.
  6. Inform the editor of suspected plagiarism, redundant publication, data irregularities, or other ethical concerns.
  7. Avoid requesting unnecessary citations or using the review process to promote their own work.
  8. Not upload unpublished manuscripts or confidential review materials to unauthorized AI systems.
  9. Remain responsible for their reviews and not delegate scholarly evaluation to AI tools.

Editorial Independence and Submissions by Editors

Creative Science is owned and financially supported by Sakon Nakhon Rajabhat University. The university exercises no influence over peer review, editorial decisions, or the content of published articles. Editorial decisions are based solely on scientific quality, originality, and relevance to the journal’s scope, and are made independently of the publisher, funders, advertisers, and institutional interests.

Manuscripts submitted by editors, members of the editorial board, or the Editor-in-Chief are subject to the same standards as all other submissions and are handled under the following safeguards:

  1. The submitting editor is excluded from all editorial handling of the manuscript.
  2. The manuscript is assigned to an independent editor with no conflict of interest.
  3. The submitting editor has no access to reviewer identities, review reports, or decision records.
  4. Reviewers are selected independently and must have no conflict of interest with the submitting editor.
  5. The editorial role of the submitting author is disclosed in the published article where appropriate.