Ethical Concerns in Human or Animal Subjects
Creative Science requires research involving human participants or animals to comply with applicable ethical standards, institutional requirements, and relevant laws and regulations. Authors must provide sufficient information to demonstrate that their research was conducted responsibly and with appropriate ethical oversight.
Research Involving Human Participants
Research involving human participants, human biological materials, or identifiable personal data must follow the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki and applicable institutional and national requirements.
Authors shall:
- Obtain approval from an appropriate Institutional Review Board (IRB), Research Ethics Committee, or equivalent body when required.
- Identify the approving committee and provide the approval number or reference, where applicable.
- Obtain informed consent from participants when required and explain the consent procedures in the manuscript.
- Protect participants' privacy, confidentiality, and personal information.
- Obtain appropriate consent for publishing identifiable photographs, personal information, or case details.
- Apply additional safeguards when research involves children, vulnerable individuals, or participants with limited capacity to provide informed consent.
- Disclose any formal exemption or waiver of ethics review or informed consent, including the basis for that determination.
Authors must include an ethics statement in the manuscript when applicable.
Example: Ethics approval
"This study was approved by the [Name of Ethics Committee] (Approval No. [Number]). Informed consent was obtained from all participants, as applicable."
Example: Ethics exemption
"The [Name of Ethics Committee or Authorized Body] determined that this study was exempt from ethics review (Reference No. [Number], where applicable)."
Authors must not claim exemption from ethics review without a valid basis under the relevant institutional or regulatory requirements.
Clinical Trial Registration
Prospective clinical trials involving human participants should be registered in a publicly accessible registry recognized by the World Health Organization (for example, the Thai Clinical Trials Registry or ClinicalTrials.gov) before the enrolment of the first participant. The registry name and registration number must be stated in the manuscript.
Research Involving Animals
Research involving animals must comply with applicable animal-welfare regulations and institutional ethical requirements, and should be reported in accordance with the ARRIVE guidelines.
Authors shall:
- Obtain approval from an authorized animal ethics committee when required.
- Follow relevant institutional, national, and internationally recognized animal-care guidelines.
- Apply the principles of Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement (the 3Rs), where applicable.
- Minimize unnecessary pain, distress, and suffering.
- Describe the animal species, number of animals, experimental procedures, and relevant welfare measures.
- Report the use of anesthesia, analgesia, humane endpoints, and euthanasia methods when applicable.
- Identify the approving committee and provide the ethics approval number or reference, where applicable.
Example: Animal ethics approval
"All animal procedures were approved by the [Name of Animal Ethics Committee] (Approval No. [Number]) and conducted in accordance with applicable animal-welfare guidelines."
Ethical Compliance and Editorial Review
The journal may request ethics approval documents, informed consent information, or other supporting evidence when necessary.
Ethics approval does not prevent the journal from examining credible concerns about the conduct or reporting of a study.
Manuscripts that do not meet applicable ethical requirements may be rejected. Ethical concerns identified after publication will be addressed under the journal's procedures for dealing with research misconduct.