• Nipon Boonkumkrong Lecturer, Department of Mechanical engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Kasem Bundit University
  • Sinchai Chinvorarat Lecturer, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, King Mongkut’s University of Technology, North Bangkok


Aeroelasticity, Flutter suppression, Modern control Theory


Aeroelasticity is the study of the mutual interaction that takes place among aerodynamic, elastic, and inertia forces acting on aircraft structures exposed to an airstream. Aircraft structures are not completely rigid and aeroelastic phenomena arising when structural deformations induce changes in aerodynamic forces. The aeroelastic phenomena include flutter, divergence, control reversal or effectiveness, etc. This paper presents the investigations of flutter suppression control scheme with modern control theory. These techniques are important for the designs of modern aircraft. The flutter is now a part of aircraft certification and flight envelope expansion.


Collar AR. The expanding domain of aeroelasticity. The Aeronautical Journal 1946;50: 613-36.

Panda C, Venkatasubramani SRP. Aeroelasticity - In general and flutter phenomenon. Proceedings of 2009 Second International Conference on Emerging Trends in Engineering & Technology; 2009 Dec. 16-18, Nagpur, India.

Wikipedia. Braniff Flight 542 [Internet] 2021 [cited 2021 March 8]. Available from:

Wikipedia. Crash of a BROB G180 spn in Mindelheim-Mattsies: 1 Killed. [Internet] 2021 [cited 2021 March 8]. Available from:

Kehoe MW. A Historical overview of flight flutter testing. California: NASA, Scientific and Technical Information Program; 1995. Technical Memorandum 4720.

Wright JR, Cooper JE. Introduction to aircraft aeroelasticity and loads. 2nd edition. West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons Ltd; 2015.

Battoo RS. A Beginners guide to literature in the field of aeroelasticity. Cranfield: College of Aeronautics, Cranfield University; 1997. COA Report no. 9712.

Garrick IE, Reed III WH. Historical development of aircraft flutter. Journal of Aircraft 1981;18(11):897-912.

Rose J BR, Jinu GR. A Study on aeroelastic flutter suppression and its control measures - past and future. International Journal of Engineering and Technology (IJET) 2014;6(2): 960-73.

Kamakoti R, Shyy W. Fluid–structure interaction for aeroelastic applications. Progress in Aerospace Sciences 2004;40:535-58.

Livne E. Aircraft active flutter suppression: state of the art and technology maturation needs. Journal of Aircraft 2018;55(1):410-50.

Fanson JL, Caughey TK. Positive position feedback control for large space structures. AIAA Journal 1990;28(4):717-24.

Balas GJ. Linear, parameter-varying control and its application to aerospace systems. Proceedings of 23rd International congress of aeronautical sciences; 2002 Sept 8-13, Toronto, Canada.

Burns RS. Advanced control engineering, 1st edition. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, Linacre house; 2001.

Moore JB, Hotz AF, Gangsaas D. Adaptive flutter suppression as a supplement to LQG based aircraft control. IFAC Identification and System Parameter Estimation 1982. 1359-64.

Moore JB, Chakravarty A, Gangsaas D. Adaptive flutter suppression. IFAC Identification and System Parameter Estimation 1985; 345-9.

Chakravarty A, Moore JB. Aircraft flutter suppression via adaptive LQG control. Proceedings of American Control Conference; 1986 June 18-20, Seattle, USA p. 488-93.

Horikawa H, Dowell EH. An elementary explanation of the flutter Mechanism with active feedback controls. Journal of Aircraft 1979;16(4):225-32.

Juang JN, Phan M. Identification of system, observer, and controller from closed-loop experimental data. Journal of guidance, control and dynamics 1994;17(1):91-6.

Norlander T, Nilsson BO, Ring D, Jahansson U. A Study on active flutter detection and control. Proceedings of the IEEE National Aerospace & Electronics Conference; 2000 Oct 12; Dayton, OH, USA.

Choi SB, Xu H, Mirmirani MD. LQG control of a CFD-based aeroelastic wing Model. Proceedings of the 42nd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control; 2003 December; Maui, Hawaii, USA.

Moosavi MR, Oskouei ARN, Khelil A. Flutter of subsonic wing. Thin-Walled Structure 2005;43:617-27.

Mevel L, Goursat M, Benveniste A, Basseville M. Aircraft flutter test design using identification and simulation: a SCILAB toolbox. Proceedings of 2005 IEEE Conference on Control Applications; 2005 Aug 28-31, Toronto, ON, Canada.

McEver MA, Ardelean EV, Cole DG, Clark RL. Active control and closed-loop identification of flutter instability in typical section airfoil. Journal of guidance, control and dynamics 2007;30(3):733-40.

Lum KY, Lai KL. Identification of a Hammerstein model for wing flutter analysis using CFD data and correlation method. Proceedings of the 2010 American Control Conference; 2010 June 30, Baltimore, MD, USA.

Mahmoodi SN, Aagaah MR, Ahmadian M. Active vibration control of aerospace structures using a modified positive position feedback method. Proceedings of 2009 American Control Conference; 2009 June 10-12, St. Louis, MO, USA.

Wenmin Q, Rui H, Haiyan H, Yonghui Z. Active flutter suppression of a multiple-actuated-wing wind tunnel model. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 2014;27(6):1451-60.

Feixin C, Jike L, Yanmao C. Flutter analysis of an airfoil with nonlinear damping using equivalent linearization. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 2014;27(1):59-64.

Nguyen NT, Swei S, Ting E. Adaptive linear quadratic Gaussian optimal control Modification for flutter suppression of adaptive wing. Proceedings of AIAA Infotech @ Aerospace; 2015 Jan 5-9, Kissimmee, Florida, USA.

Singh KV. Active aeroelastic control with time delay for targeted flutter modes. Aerospace science and technology 2015;43:281-8.

Visser M, Navalkar ST, van Wingerden JW. LPV Model identification for flutter prediction: a comparison of methods. IFAC-Papers Online 2015;48(26):121-6.

Huang R, Qian W, Hu H, Zhao Y. Design of active flutter suppression and wind-tunnel tests of a wing model involving a control delay. Journal of Fluids and structure 2015:55:409-27.

Theis J, Pfifer H, Seiler P. Robust control design for active flutter suppression. Proceedings of AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference; 2016 Jan 4-8, San Diego, California, USA.

Liu X, Sun Q, Cooper JE. LQG based model predictive control for gust load alleviation. Aerospace Science and Technology 2017;71:499-509.

Al-Hajjar AMH, Al-Jiboory AK. LPV Modeling and control for active flutter suppression of a smart airfoil. Proceedings of AIAA Guidance, Navigation, and Control Conference; 2018 Jan 8-12, Kissimmee, Florida, USA.

Liu Q, Xu Y, Kurths J. Active vibration suppression of a novel airfoil model with fractional order viscoelastic constitutive relationship. Journal of Sound and vibration 2018;432:50-64.

Heeg J. Analytical and experimental investigation of flutter suppression by piezoelectric actuation. Virginia: NASA; 1993. Technical Paper 3241.

Meyer JL, Harrington WB, Agrawal BN, Song G. Application of piezoceramics to vibration suppression of a spacecraft flexible appendage. Proceedings of AIAA Guidance, Navigation and Control Conference; 1996 July 29-31, San Diego, CA, USA

Meyer JL, Harrington WB, Agrawal BN, Song G. Vibration suppression of a spacecraft flexible appendage using smart Material. Smart Materials and Structures 1998;7:95-104.

Giurgiutiu V. Active-materials induced-strain actuation for aeroelastic vibration control. The Shock and Vibration Digest 2000;32 (5):355-68.

Suleman A, Costa AP. Adaptive control of an aeroelastic flight vehicle using piezoelectric actuators. Computers & Structures 2004;82:1303-14.

Kawai N. Flutter control of wind tunnel model using a single element of Piezoceramic actuator. Proceedings of 24th International congress of the Aeronautical Sciences; 2004 Aug 29, Yokohama, Japan.

Ardelean EV, McEver MA, Cole DG, Clark RL. Active flutter control with v-stack piezoelectric flap actuator. Journal of Aircraft 2006;43(2):482-6.

Makihara K, Onoda J, Minesugi K. Flutter suppression of cantilevered plate wing using piezoelectric materials. KSAS International journal 2006;7(2):1-16.

Han JH, Tani J, Qiu J. Active flutter suppression of a lifting surface using piezoelectric actuation and modern control theory. Journal of sound and vibration 2006;291:706-22.

Li L, Yu S, Kawai N, Matsushita H. Active flutter suppression control using piezo-ceramic actuators, intelligent control and automation. Proceedings of 2006 6th World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation; 2006 June 21-23, Dalian, China.

Raja S, Upadhya AR. Active control of wing flutter using piezo actuated surface. Journal of Aircraft 2007;44(1):71-80.

Munteanu E. Piezo smart composite wing with LQG/LTR control. Proceedings of 2008 IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics; 2008 June 30 - July 2, Cambridge, UK.

Papatheou E, Wei X, Jiffri S, Prandina M, Tehrani MG, Bode S. Flutter control using vibration test data: theory, rig design and preliminary results. Proceedings of International Seminar on Modal Analysis (ISMA2012); 2012 Sept 17-19, Leuven, Belgium.

Tsushima N, Su W. Passive and active piezoelectric effects on flutter suppression of highly flexible wings. Proceedings of First International Symposium on Flutter and its Application; 2016 May 15-17, Minato-ku, Tokyo, Japan, p. 67-76

Asadi D, Farsadi T. Active flutter control of thin-walled wing-engine system using piezoelectric actuators. Aerospace Science and Technology 2020;102:1-22.

Ricketts RH. Experimental aeroelasticity - history, status and future in brief. Proceedings of 31st Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference; 1990 April 2 - April 4, Long Beach, CA, USA.

Brenner MJ, Lind RC, Voracek DF. Overview of recent flight flutter testing research at NASA Dryden. Dryden: NASA; 1997. NASA Technical Memorandum 4792.

Cooper JE. Towards faster and safer flight flutter testing. Proceedings of Symposium on Reduction of Military Vehicle Acquisition time and Cost through advanced Modelling and Virtual Simulation; 2002 April 22-25, Paris, France.

Qin N. CFD for better understanding of wind tunnel tests. Proceedings of 1st Symposium on Integrating CFD and Experiments in Aerodynamics; 2003 Sept, Glasgow, UK.

Marqui Junior CD, Rebolho DC, Belo EM, Marques FD, Tsunaki RH. Design of an experimental flutter mount system. J. Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. & Eng. 2007; 29(3):246-52.

Sundresan M, Joseph DR, Karthick R, Joe JCSS. Review of aeroelasticity testing technology. Procedia Engineering 2012;38:2297-311.

Papatheou E, Tantaroudas ND, Ronch AD. Active control for flutter suppression: an experimental investigation. Proceedings of International Forum on Aeroelasticity and Structural Dynamics (IFASD); 2013 Jun 24 – 27, United Kingdom.

Jiang X, Fei Y, Ji L. Overview of recent flutter test key techniques for modern civil aircraft inspection airworthiness. Int. J. Mech. Eng. Autom. 2015;2(5):216-25.

Tang D, Dowell EH. Experimental aeroelastic models design and wind tunnel testing for correlation with new theory. Aerospace 2016:3(2):1-25.






บทความวิชาการ (Academic Article)