Smart city's trends, architectures, components, and challenges: A systematic review and building an initial model for Indonesia
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Smart cities are faced with the challenges of systematically initiating the strategies needed to implement predetermined goals according to their plan. Therefore, this study aims to identify smart cities components and build an initial model that can be used for smart cities initiatives in Indonesia. The systematic review methods were used to overview research trends, architecture, components, and challenges to build an initial model for Indonesia. The systematic review results show popular topics, such as the standardization of a smart city and the strategies used to determine relevant models in each city's uniqueness and context. The results also identified thirteen smart city components and their challenges. Furthermore, this study's novelty is proposed the smart city's initial models with the smart government as a key component and to be a centre of other smart city components. The triangulation method determined the research validation using systematic review finding, expert judgment, and a questionnaire for collecting random data from 66 respondents from various cities in Indonesia. The collected survey data and initial models were validated by expert judgment, which showed that the proposed smart city's initial model component's agreement is 90%. In future, these results may be used to develop an assessment in smart cities implementation.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
Bibri SE, Krogstie J. Smart sustainable cities of the future: an extensive interdisciplinary literature review. Sustain Cities Soc. 2017;31:183-212.
Purnomo F, Meyliana, Prabowo H. Smart city indicators: a systematic literature review. J Telecomm Electron Comput Eng. 2016;8:161-4.
Zanella A, Bui N, Castellani A, Vangelista L, Zorzi M. Internet of things for smart cities. IEEE Internet Things J. 2014;1(1):22-32.
Silva B, Khan M, Han K. Towards sustainable smart cities: a review of trends, architectures, components, and open challenges in smart cities. Sustain Cities Soc. 2018;38:697-713.
Rodriguez-Bolivar MP. Transforming city governments for successful smart cities. New York: Springer; 2015.
Zygiaris S. Smart city reference model: assisting planners to conceptualize the building of smart city innovation ecosystems. J Knowl Econ. 2013;4:217-31.
Creswell JW. Research design: qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. California: SAGE Publications; 2013.
Kitchenham B, Charters S. Guidelines for performing systematic literature reviews in software engineering. EBSE Technical Report. United Kingdom: Keele University and University of Durham; 2007.
Haini SI, Ab Rahim NZ, Megat N, Ibrahim R. Factors influencing the adoption of open government data in the public sector: a systematic literature review. Int J Adv Sci Eng Inform Technol. 2020;10(2):611.
Raaijen T, Daneva M. Depicting the smarter cities of the future: a systematic literature review and field study. 2017 Smart City Symposium Prague (SCSP); 2017 May 25-26; Prague, Czech Republic. New York: IEEE; 2017. p. 1-10.
Clement SJ, McKee DW, Xu J. Service-oriented reference architecture for smart cities. 2017 IEEE Symposium on Service-Oriented System Engineering (SOSE); 2017 Apr 6-9; San Francisco, USA. New York: IEEE; 2017. p. 81-5.
Kitchenham B, Brereton P. A systematic review of systematic review process research in software engineering. Inf Softw Technol. 2013;55(12):2049-75.
Anthopoulos LG. Understanding smart cities: a tool for smart government or an industrial trick?. Greece: Springer; 2017. p. 1-293.
Pettit CJ, Bakelmun A, Lieske SN, Glackin S, Hargroves KJ, Thomson G, et al. Planning support systems for smart cities. City Cult Soc. 2018;12:13-24.
Oktaria D, Suhardi, Kurniawan NB. Smart city services : a systematic literature review. 2017 International Conference on Information Technology Systems and Innovation (ICITSI); 2017 Oct 23-24; Bandung, Indonesia. New York: IEEE; 2017. p. 206-13.
Ibrahim M, El-Zaart A, Adams C. Smart sustainable cities roadmap: readiness for transformation towards urban sustainability. Sustain Cities Soc. 2018;37:530-40.
Chauhan S, Kaushik A. Evaluating citizen acceptance of unique identification number in India: an empirical study. Int J Electron Govern Res. 2016;12(3):223-42.
Monzon A. Smart cities concept and challenges - bases for the assessment of smart city projects. 4th International Conference on Smart Cities and Green ICT Systems; 2015 May 20-22; Lisbon, Portugal. Cham: Springer; 2015. p. 17-31.
Vu K, Hartley K. Promoting smart cities in developing countries: policy insights from Vietnam. Telecomm Pol. 2017;42(10): 845-59.
Das RK, Misra H. Smart city and e-governance: exploring the connect in the context of local development in India. 2017 Fourth International Conference on eDemocracy & eGovernment (ICEDEG); 2017 Apr 19-21; Quito, Ecuador. New York: IEEE; 2017. p. 232-3.
Barns S. Smart cities and urban data platforms: designing interfaces for smart governance. City Cult Soc. 2018;12:5-12.
Fernandez-Anez V, Fernandez-Guell J, Giffinger R. Smart city implementation and discourses: an integrated conceptual model. The case of Vienna. Cities. 2018;78:4-16.
Tan SY, Taeihagh A. Smart city governance in developing countries: a systematic literature review. Sustainability 2020;12(3):899.
Pettit C, Bakelmun A, Lieske SN, Glackin S, Charlie K, Thomson G, et al. Planning support systems for smart cities. City Cult Soc. 2018;12:13-24.
Gil-Garcia JR, Pardo TA, Nam T. Smarter as the new urban agenda. New York: Springer; 2016.
Halepoto IA, Sahito AA, Uqaili MA, Chowdhry BS, Riaz T. Multi-criteria assessment of smart city transformation based on SWOT analysis. The 5th National Symposium on Information Technology: Towards New Smart World (NSITNSW); 2015 Feb 17-19; Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. New York: IEEE; 2015. p. 1-6.
Hollands RG. Will the real smart city please stand up?. City. 2008;12(3):303-20.
Aina YA. Achieving smart sustainable cities with GeoICT support: the Saudi evolving smart cities. Cities. 2017;71:49-58.
Randhawa A, Kumar A. Exploring sustainability of smart development initiatives in India. Int J Sustain Built Environ. 2017;6(2):701-10.
Kylili A, Fokaides PA. European smart cities: the role of zero energy buildings. Sustain Cities Soc. 2015;15:86-95.
Hu X, Chu THS, Chan HCB, Leung VCM. Vita: a crowdsensing-oriented mobile cyber-physical system. IEEE Trans Emerg Top Comput. 2013;1(1):148-65.
Harrison C, Eckman B, Hamilton R, Hartswick P, Kalagnanam J, Paraszczak J, et al. Foundations for smarter cities. IBM J Res Dev. 2010;54(4):350-65.
Suakanto S, Supangkat SH, Suhardi, Saragih R. Smart city dashboard for integrating various data of sensor networks. International Conference on ICT for Smart Society; 2013 Jun 13-14; Jakarta, Indonesia. New York: IEEE; 2013. p. 1-5.
Yin C, Xiong Z, Chen H, Wang J, Cooper D, David B. A literature survey on smart cities. Sci China Inform Sci. 2015;58(10):1-18.
Khatoun R, Zeadally S. Smart cities: concepts, architectures, research opportunities. Comm ACM. 2016;59(8):46-57.
Nam T, Pardo TA. Conceptualizing smart city with dimensions of technology, people, and institutions. The 12th Annual International Digital Government Research Conference on Digital Government Innovation in Challenging Times; 2011 Jun 12-15; College Park, USA. New York: Association for Computing Machinery; 2011. p. 282-91.
Batty M, Axhausen KW, Giannotti F, Pozdnoukhov A, Bazzani A, Wachowicz M, et al. Smart cities of the future. Eur Phys J Spec Top. 2012;214:481-518.
Botta A, De Donato W, Persico V, Pescape A. Integration of cloud computing and internet of things: a survey. Future Generat Comput Syst. 2016;56:684-700.
Hassanien AE, Khamparia A, Gupta D, Slowik A. Cognitive internet of medical things for smart healthcare. New York: Springer; 2021.
Rajesh G, Raajini XM, Sagayam KM, Dang H. A statistical approach for high order epistasis interaction detection for prediction of diabetic macular edema. Inform Med Unlocked. 2020;20:100362.
Neirotti P, De Marco A, Cagliano AC, Mangano G, Scorrano F. Current trends in smart city initiatives: some stylized facts. Cities 2014;38:25-36.
Afonso RA, Dos K, Brito S, Do Nascimento CH, Garcia VC, Alvaro A. Brazilian smart cities: using a maturity model to measure and compare inequality in cities. The 16th Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research; 2015 May 27-30; Phoenix, USA. New York: Association for Computing Machinery; 2015. p. 230-8.
Al Nuaimi E, Al Neyadi H, Mohamed N, Al-Jaroodi J. Applications of big data to smart cities. J Internet Serv Appl. 2015;6(1):1-15.
Ben Letaifa S. How to strategize smart cities: revealing the SMART model. J Bus Res. 2015;68(7):1414-19.
Bhushan B, Sinha P, Sagayam KM, Andrew J. Untangling blockchain technology: a survey on state of the art, security threats, privacy services, applications and future research directions. Comput Electr Eng. 2020;90:106897.
Wenge R, Zhang X, Dave C, Chao L, Hao S. Smart city architecture: a technology guide for implementation and design challenges. China Comm. 2014;11(3):56-69.
Dewi MA, Hidayanto A, Purwandari B, Kosandi M, Budi N. Smart city readiness model using technology-organization-environment (TOE.) framework and its effect on adoption decision. The 22nd Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems - Opportunities and Challenges for the Digitized Society: Are We Ready?; 2018 Jun 26-30; Yokohama, Japan. Georgia: Association for Information Systems; 2018. p. 268-81.
Achmad KA, Nugroho L, Djunaedi A. Widyawan W. Smart city readiness based on smart city council's readiness framework. Int J Electr Comput Eng. 2018;8(1):271-9.
Firmansyah HS, Supangkat SH, Arman AA, Nugraha R. Searching smart city in Indonesia through maturity model analysis (case study in 10 cities). 2017 International Conference on ICT for Smart Society (ICISS); 2017 Sep 18-19; Tangerang, Indonesia. New York: IEEE; 2017. p. 1-6.
Lopes NV. Smart governance: a key factor for smart cities implementation. 2017 IEEE International Conference on Smart Grid and Smart Cities (ICSGSC); 2017 Jul 23-26; Singapore. New York: IEEE; 2017. p. 277-82.
Chourabi H, Nam T, Walker S, Gil-Garcia JR, Mellouli S, Nahon K, et al. Understanding smart cities: an integrative framework. The 45th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences; 2012 Jan 4-7; Maui, USA. New York: IEEE; 2012. p. 2289-97.
Cronemberger F, Gil-Garcia JR. Big data and analytics as strategies to generate public value in smart cities: proposing an integrative framework. Cham: Springer; 2019. p. 247-67.
Giffinger R, Fertner C, Kramar H, Klasek R, Pichler-Milanovic N, Maijers E. Smart cities ranking of European medium-sized cities. Vienna: Vienna University of Technology; 2007.
Caragliu A, Del Bo C, Nijkamp P. Smart cities in Europe. J Urban Technol. 2011;18(0048):65-82.
Lazaroiu GC, Roscia M. Definition methodology for the smart cities model. Energy. 2012;47(1):326-32.
Lombardi P, Giordano S, Farouh H, Yousef W. Modelling the smart city performance. Innovat Eur J Soc Sci Res. 2012;25(2):137-49.
Dameri R, Cocchia A. Smart city and digital city: twenty years of terminology evolution. The X Conference of the Italian Chapter of AIS; 2013 Dec 14; Milan, Italy. Heidelberg: Springer; 2013. p. 1-8.
Cocchia A. Smart and digital city: a systematic literature review. In: Dameri R, Rosenthal-Sabroux C, editors. Smart city. Cham: Springer; 2014. p. 13-43.
Albino V, Berardi U, Dangelico RM. Smart cities: definitions, dimensions, performance, and initiatives. J Urban Technol. 2015;22(1):3-21.
Anthopoulos LG, Reddick CG. Smart city and smart government: synonymous or complementary? Proceedings of the International World Wide Web Conference Committee (IW3C2); 2016 Apr 11-15; Montreal, Canada. Switzerland: ACM; 2016. p. 351-5.
Chauhan S, Agarwal N, Kar AK. Addressing big data challenges in smart cities: a systematic literature review. Info. 2016;18(4):73-90.
Pramanik MI, Lau R, Demirkan H, Azad M. Smart health: big data enabled health paradigm within smart cities. Expert Syst Appl. 2017;87:370-83.
Praharaj S, Han JH, Hawken S. Urban innovation through policy integration: critical perspectives from 100 smart cities mission in India. City Cult Soc. 2017;12:35-43.
Mohammadi M, Al-Fuqaha A. Enabling cognitive smart cities using big data and machine learning: approaches and challenges. IEEE Comm Mag. 2018;56(2):94-101.
Sharma K, Tayal S. Indian smart city ranking model using taxicab distance-based approach. Energy Syst. 2019:1-18.
Li X, Fong PS, Dai S, Li Y. Towards sustainable smart cities: an empirical comparative assessment and development pattern optimization in China. J Clean Prod. 2019;215:730-43.
Sanchez-Teba EM, Bermudez-Gonzalez GJ. Are smart-city projects citizen-centered?. Soc Sci. 2019;8(11):309.
Vasuaninchita M, Vongmanee V, Rattanawong W. The novel paradigm of economics driven for local smart sustain cities modeling using exploratory factor analysis and planning technique using fuzzy evaluation decision making. Sustainability. 2020;12(3):793.
Bhushan B, Khamparia A, Sagayam KM, Sharma SK, Ahad MA, Debnath NC. Blockchain for smart cities: a review of architectures, integration trends and future research directions. Sustain Cities Soc. 2020;61:102360.